Fleeting Frustrations 6.5: “We Can’t Have Anything, Can We?”

Fleeting Frustrations 6.5_ “We Can’t Have Anything, Can We_”.png

Star Wars Episode IX: Rise of the Skywalker is the focus for the cover story for Vanity Fair’s Summer 2019 issue and readers were “blessed” with dual covers – one with Adam Driver’s Kylo Ren and the other with Daisy Ridley’s Rey. Written by The Magicians’ author Lev Grossman and interspersed with photos from Annie Leibovitz, this massive article was the talk of the Twittersphere for days after its release.

Grossman’s Vanity Fair article is… alright. It doesn’t really focus on Finn, but I gave up on folks remembering that Finn was supposed to be the male hero of the franchise – and just as heroic as Rey – back when The Last Jedi came out.

In the article, there’s a particularly stunning photograph of John Boyega’s Finn and newcomer Naomi Ackie’s Jannah sitting astride a pair of orbaks – an equine adjacent species new to audiences. It’s an iconic photo as well because Jannah is only the third Black female character with dialogue in the franchise – and the first to be in a main trilogy – and this is the first time that the Star Wars franchise has had two Black characters interacting like this.

It’s something that clearly belongs to Finn and to Jannah –

So, of course, someone had to make it about Kylo Ren Ben Solo.

kylo ugh

In this screenshot of a tweet ulploaded by twitter user @darthsherey, Kylo Ren is portrayed riding an orbak. The user sharing this screenshot calls out the art as:  “a constant reminder that fandom will always prioritize their white faves and take anything good characters of colour get for them”

I have a currently scrapped What Fandom Racism Looks Like installment dedicated to this thing the Star Wars fandom has been doing since John Boyega was announced as starring opposite Daisy Ridley: cutting him out of the focus of a scene or still and replacing him with Adam Driver.

This is technically not that because Finn isn’t literally being cut out here the way he often is by Kylo Ren’s photoshop-happy stans.

But it’s still shitty because of what it represents: a need to center Kylo Ren in everything and to decenter Finn across as many possible avenues.

At first glance, if you know nothing about what Black fans of Finn and John Boyega have been witnessing and experiencing in the Star Wars sequel trilogy fandom, this isn’t a big deal. 

Right?

Because fan artists can create what they want.

Or something like that.

Problem is, that this fun and fantastic image of Kylo is in and of itself a red flag thanks to how it serves to center whiteness and remind fans that once again, Finn isn’t the hero they wanted. (And that it’s got a lot more to do with his skin tone than most folks are willing to admit to.)

Did the artists go into this intending to erase Finn or piss off Black fans?

Doubtful.

But that’s definitely what I and other Black people in the Star Wars fandom keep having to deal with in times like this: a selfish centering of white people and erasure of Black characters that leads to us being called selfish.

Us.

Okay.


Kylo Ren had one of two Vanity Fair covers, he’s written about really well in the article and has a smidge more text time than John Boyega – who was again, treated like the male lead in The Force Awakens press stuff – does. He’s been the focus of tons of speculation and expectation from fans and media people alike. He’ll probably wind up with a major narrative focus in Rise of the Skywalker that feeds their hunger for a white villain redemption arc.

And with all that Kylo gets from the canon –

The fandom still has to take something that is Finn’s.

Because that’s what the Kylo Ren fandom does: it takes things (experiences, friendships, backstories) that Finn has or the very nature of his character and passes them on to Kylo Ren Ben Solo.

Finn’s deep relationship with Rey, his origins as a child soldier brainwashed, abused, and forced into the First Order, his heroic personality and innate goodness, his CLOTHING at one point, and now this –

star-wars-feature-vf-2019-summer-embed-06

PHOTOGRAPH BY ANNIE LEIBOVITZ.

Finn is literally not allowed to have anything for himself in this fandom.

Everything that he has or is, the Star Wars fandom seems to think Kylo Ren deserves more.

Somehow.

And generally, when  Black fans point out how Black characters in fandom spaces get rewritten or literally erased in order to center white characters instead, we’re framed as selfish.

Even as white fans take the little bits of representation we get and aspects of nerd media’s few Black characters and erase them wholesale or give those things to their white favorites like Kylo Ren.

Look –

It’d be great if Black fans could just enjoy things. It’d be wonderful if Black fans didn’t have to fight tooth and nail to defend Black characters from fandom.

However, we live in a world/are in fandoms where Black people are given crumbs for representation and white fans will still sweep said crumbs onto their own plates for their white favorites.

And when Black fans point out what they’re doing, that they’re taking something from Black characters – and, trying to take it from Black fans – by erasing them or giving their accomplishments, backstories, or plots to white characters, we’re called selfish. We’re accused of overreacting.

Twice before this, I remember other times Black fans have been accused of being selfish/overreacting when it came to defending Black characters from fandom. Both times it’s been FROM ANTIBLACKNESS.

Black fans were accused of being selfish and gate-keeping when we demanded that fandom treat the characters and setting of Black Panther with respect when writing fic and headcanons. (And considering how much of the fandom zoomed on ahead to write/draw racist fanworks… we were definitely not in the wrong.)

We were also accused of overreacting and policing fans when we talked about how John Boyega’s character in Pacific Rim Uprising was treated like a blip by half of the fandom and turned into a big ole black brute by the other.

I know folks out here have decided anti-Black microaggressions don’t exist in fandom, but like…for the past three years, the second Finn gets something Kylo stans go “what if Ben had it instead” and gives it to him. Often while vilifying Finn in the process.

How is that not a microaggression? How is that not anti-Black on ANY level?

It’s messed up that Finn is not allowed to have ANYTHING that the fandom thinks Ben Solo deserves instead.

On the surface level or to outsiders in the fandom, it may seem like such a small thing to be concerned about when there’s “real racism” afoot in the world, but it’s indicative of a huge problem in and out of fandom spaces:

Black people aren’t seen as valuable enough as people or as characters to be treated with respect and not have aspects of ourselves/characters that look like us distributed piecemeal to white people and characters.

Advertisements

About senzavoi

Zina writes about comics, nerd history, and ridiculous romance novels when not working frantically on her first collection of short stories and complaining about stuff. One day, she'll settle down and write that novel.
This entry was posted in Rants and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Fleeting Frustrations 6.5: “We Can’t Have Anything, Can We?”

  1. L.J. Lee says:

    I saw this on Tumblr and it made me sick. It’s just part of a consistent pattern of fandom being green with envy at Finn’s story and taking it for their BS woobie Ben Solo.

    Finn was abused and groomed since he was a small child? Let’s insist this is BS’s canonical past.
    Finn was the first person in memory to ask Rey if she’s okay? Let’s wax poetic about how BS is the first and only person to care about Rey.
    Finn holds Rey’s hand? Let’s call that sexual harassment and go gaga over BS’s “romantic” assault and kidnap of Rey.
    Finn tells Rey “We came back for you” and it’s a moving moment that involves some healing for a lifetime of trauma for Rey? Let’s use that line for BS and Rey instead.
    Finn and Rey are best friends who are each others’ motivation for risking their lives? Time to go on and on about how BS is the only person who understands Rey, while ridiculing Finn as “friendzoned” and comparing any sex/romance between Finn and Rey to incest.
    Finn rides in the Millennium Falcon with Han? Cue the 12,391 headcanons about BS piloting the MF.
    There’s excitement building about Finn possibly leading a Stormtrooper uprising? Speculate about BS freeing the Stormtroopers.
    Finn and Jannah look fierce and regal on horseback? Love that picture, except you know how to make it even better? Yeah. Have BS take their place.

    Every time. It’s like clockwork. Between this bullshit and the untagged reylow I don’t even like browsing the main tags anymore.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Pingback: Fleeting Frustrations 6.5: “We Can’t Have Anything, Can We?” — Stitch’s Media Mix – Geeking Out about It

  3. Kiki says:

    I wanted to get excited about the VF issue but everything about it + the trailer signaled to me that Finn is no longer considered to be a major character. That it’s all about Kylo and Rey. Which is a huge letdown as TFA with Finn and Rey’s story at its centre was what made me care anything at all about Star Wars in the first place :/.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. AmyCat says:

    Not even black here and I find this infuriating. Then again, I’m apparently a weirdo ‘cause I think Finn is worth 100 of Kylo F’ing Ren The Entitled Whiny White Boy-Child. I want to see Kylo DIE IN A FIRE (or a lava pit; that’ll be okay too). I want to see Rey rip Ren’s pouty face off, and then go off with Finn to boink like bunnies.
    Kylo Ren is one of the most overrated characters in the whole “Star Wars” universe.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s