What Fandom Racism Looks Like: White Prioritization

What Fandom Racism Looks Like.png
I think my pal Holly over at DiverseHighFantasy was one of (if not the) first people to use “white prioritization” in a fannish context in a piece on The Walking Dead fandom and the Rick/Michonne ship. So I’d like to open my piece by shouting out to hers.
As I’ve researched, I’ve found a really great starting point for talking about “white prioritization” in Sincere Kirabo’s definition of “white-centeredness” in this piece entitled “On White Supremacy And The Nature Of Norms”:

White-centeredness is a deeply-rooted aspect of U.S. culture. White-centeredness denotes the centrality of white representation that permeates every facet of our dominant culture. It upholds as “normal” and “expected” the ubiquity of language, ideas, prejudices, preferences, values, social mores, and worldviews established by the white perspective.

Like white-centeredness, “white prioritization” is all about focusing on white people alone. It’s a term that refers to the way that people constantly centers whiteness (white men and women primarily) and how that centering comes almost exclusively at the expense of people of color. It’s all about focusing on white experiences and making sure that everything is about white people – even the experiences of people of color.

White prioritization largely looks the same in fandom and media. White people – fictional and otherwise – are seen as more valid and more important than people of color. In media and the fandoms that it spawns, this prioritization takes many forms:

  • Focusing on minor white characters or villains above main/heroic characters of color (e.g., Hux being such a hugely popular character in the Star Wars fandom and fandom thinking that he’s “more interesting” than Finn)
  • Creating content where white characters are shoehorned into roles that should belong to a character of color (e.g., whitewashing in general, Tom Cruise playing the white main character in a film about samurai, and Kylo Ren being rewritten/drawn as a Native American for the purpose of an alternate universe).
  • The emotions of white people (characters, fans, and actors) are valued more than the emotions of people of color (e.g., “saying that Poe Dameron would be a better son to Leia than Kylo Ren/Ben Solo is ableist”, imagining made-up trauma for Loki but writing off Valkyrie’s trauma at Hela’s hands, and how the Teen Wolf fandom literally ignores Scott’s canonical trauma and PTSD)
  • Giving white characters the storylines, characterization, and traits associated with specific characters of color (e.g., Steve Roger’s “I’m on your left” comment to Sam Wilson and the meet-cute element being used for Stucky purposes, Finn’s characterization and backstory of being brainwashed into the First Order being given to “Ben Solo”, Iris West’s relationship with Barry being given to Caitlin Snow
  • Uh… literally cutting out/off people of color out of things so that the audience can now focus on the “real” stars of the fan work/edits: white people

 

In fandom and media, people color simply don’t matter even in works where they make up the main audience. They’re not assumed to be as valuable as white characters in the same franchise because well… folks are racist.

We live in a world where people of color are seen as less valuable than white people. This translates to fandom where the value that fans place on characters influences the way folks talk people of color and what content they create for them.

Fandom’s whole thing about neatly snipping characters of color from their own narratives and edging out people of color from historic successes (e.g., focusing on Agent Ross or Bucky (who only had like ten seconds of screen time) in your Black Panther focus rather than on the you know… Black people in this movie) is racist because it’s yet another way that they show how little people of color matter to white folks in fandom.

Think about how many people went out of their way after watching Black Panther to focus on white characters – many of which weren’t even in the movie – instead of on the characters of the film. Many people rushed to place these Black characters in relation to white ones with headcanons and stories about things like how Shuri would totally school, sass, or adopt white characters or how Steve would like totally feel bad about his role in US imperialism and neo-colonialism after a Wakandan calls him a colonizer.

It feels like a repeat of stuff that we’ve seen in fandom before whenever Black characters get popular: they’re reduced to being the sidekicks or helpmates of white characters even when they’re the main characters.

It’s something that’s never reversed.

Consider how the second end credit scene of Black Panther with Bucky Barnes led to fandom centering him in Wakanda and writing tons of fanworks and headcanons about him and him alone. That wouldn’t happen with a Black character in the end credits scene of a white character – even one the Black character was more popular than.

For example: Sam Wilson’s appearance in Ant-Man didn’t lead to him getting tons of content based on that scene and hyping fans up for the character to the point where it felt like he was kind of overwhelmingly the focus of fandom.

A common cry of the called out racist is “I’m not/can’t be racist, I like [character of color]”/ [ship with character of color]”.

This claim is usually made by folks who’ve turned their blogs into shrines for certain white characters or ships between white characters. Folks that try to derail and deflect comments about their/fandom’s racism by trotting out every single character of color that they don’t actively loathe as a smokescreen. Folks whose blogs are largely devoid of the very characters of color that they profess to love so much.

Fandom is full of people that swear up and down that they really do love [x character or performer of color] even as they share and support fanworks that remove them from the stage or scene entirely in order to focus almost exclusively on white (male) characters.

Think about the fact that while fandom racism – and the folks who talk about it – generally never get to be taken seriously, this aspect to fandom racism is seen as a non-issue entirely. It isn’t seen as “real” racism because of the whole pesky preference that leads to our fellow fans brushing off the racism they commit and support by the fact that they somehow aren’t attracted to people of color…

They just conveniently have a preference for white folks and no interest in unpacking like… any of that.

Folks in fandom thirst endlessly for white characters and basically kind of only remembers that people of color exist when they need something for their white fave to co-opt or a character to get in their fave’s way.

Advertisements

About Zina

Zina writes about comics, nerd history, and ridiculous romance novels when not working frantically on her first collection of short stories and complaining about stuff. One day, she'll settle down and write that novel.
This entry was posted in Fandom, What Fandom Racism Looks Like and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to What Fandom Racism Looks Like: White Prioritization

  1. lkeke35 says:

    A common cry of the called out racist is “I’m not/can’t be racist, I like [character of color]”/ [ship with character of color]”.

    Yes! Like most bigots, they do in fact love Black people, as long as those Black people are in their proper place as secondary to a White person, because in their mind, that’s exactly where a Black person belongs, walking behind, and propping them up. On some deep level beyond thought, White people still think of us as being on this Earth to serve their needs, and make their lives comfortable and this uninterrogated plays out in how they perform fandom.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. AmyCat says:

    Thank you for another excellent essay. You’re a valuable and much-needed voice in fandom.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.